Friday, July 28, 2017

FAKE BIRD NEWS! The Korean Crow-Tit




This Is The Korean Crow-Tit - The World's Cutest Bird!

This little birdy is a Korean crow-tit and it looks like a fluffy cotton ball with tiny wings.

It's a little poof ball!

LOOK AT ITS TINY WINGS!




The above rhapsody is from a site called Sunny Skyz, which posts mostly, I believe, sunny, funny, adorable things, which these bird pictures definitely are.

I looked up the fluffball birdie elsewhere, and it appeared on a few other bouncy, flouncy, good-news sites, along with (groannn, inevitably) Pinterest.




I quickly became enamored of this poofball, compared (on one page) with "something a little kid would make out of a cotton ball". I even made a little animation with it (somewhere below).

But then I began to have my doubts.

I began to have my doubts when I looked for information about this bird, and hit a complete and total dead end.




Wikipedia, which has entries on just about every species of bird, bee, animal and plant, had nothing at all on it, in spite of a massive entry on Korean bird species that ran into the hundreds. 

It got worse. My beloved Cornell Laboratory of Ornithology (which I refer to almost daily now that I have become a Bird Nerd) had nothing on it either. Tits, yes! There are many kinds of tits, and I have heard all the jokes. But no Korean crow-tit.

I had a growing suspicion, one I've had many times before. Somebody was having me on.




After googling around fruitlessly and only finding endless replications of the cute little fluff-balls, with no information about them at all, I came across a startling entry from a site,about a Korean "boy band" called BTS. Once I read it, I was more confused than ever:

Now the video I linked says, "They call me a try-hard", but I think it's more accurate to leave the word 'baepsae', or 'crow-tit'. This hinges on the fact that this song utilizes a well-known phrase in Korea: "If a crow-tit walks like a stork, it will tear its legs". A crow-tit is a bird with a small stride because it has short legs, and when we compare this with a stork who has much taller legs, we see that the stork would easily be able to travel farther with less effort.

(Video removed by YouTube)

The song itself mentions the stork and the crow-tit multiple times, the "crow-tits" being the generation from which BTS members come, whereas the "storks" are the generation prior. The stork generation is comprised of parents, teachers, employees- people the younger generation is meant to be able to look up to and to learn from.




So somebody probably extracted the name from that song and attached it to pictures of a very cute bird which nobody can readily identify. How many people know about the old Korean legend of the crow-tit, and how it might tear its little legs if it walks like a stork? Fans of BTS, perhaps, though this strikes me as a little obscure.

My question is, how many people accepted this fluffy little hoax without question? Quite a few, it seems. The white birdie has been around since some time last year, and I haven't seen it challenged (until now!).




BLOGGER'S P. S. I just emailed the Cornell Laboratory of Ornithology, which has never failed me yet in providing information about all things bird. That's what I love about them. There is always a human being there, and one that loves and knows about birds. Usually they get back to you post-haste.

So if and when I get an answer about the real identity of this tiny little poofball, I'll update you immediately. Myself, I can hardly wait! 

UPDATE: MUCH later, and the comments are still coming! Rosy Novelist posted these remarks, but the links weren't live, so here they are with links. 

Rosy Novelist has left a new comment on the post "FAKE BIRD NEWS! The Korean Crow-Tit":

Hi! I'm a South Korean currently studying in the U.S. I came across this blog post and couldn't help but leave a message.

So the white fluffy bird is actually a Long-tailed tit. In Korean, it's "오목눈이." This Korean YouTuber uploaded a video about how the Korean baepsae is commonly mistakened with it.

Link to video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S-mTP52IqM4. It's in Korean but when you look at 00:47, she explains with the visuals.

The long tailed tit is a common bird found throughout Europe and the Palearctic. Here is the distribution map from Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long-tailed_tit#/media/File:Schwanzmeise_(Aegithalos_caudatus)_distribution_map.png.

So, it is a lovely bird that is found throughout Eurasia. Koreans have seen it throughout its history and called it "오목눈이" while in different cultures, they are called something else.

So I think the "Korean crow tit" is not the right name for the fluffy bird because 1) Birds don't have nationalities 2) it's a long tailed tit.

The notion that it's a Japanese bird or a Korean bird or any other nationality bird is pretty ridiculous. Birds are birds and they are lovely! :)

Rosy Novelist has left a new comment on the post "FAKE BIRD NEWS! The Korean Crow-Tit":

Exactly! Baepsaes are parrotbills - brownish fluffs found in Korea as well as elsewhere. The white fluffs are long tailed tits that are migratory birds that stay from Europe to Asia.

I think this post also explains well: https://aminoapps.com/c/btsarmy/page/blog/fake-bird-news-alert-baepsae-does-not-mean-crow-tit/D8BQ_p81hPurDKYqJJKgwMxBNWMKXg17dg


76 comments:

  1. Replies
    1. Actually, I did and forgot to post it. They responded quite promptly:
      Hi Margaret,

      I love a good internet-"meme"stery!

      So, as near as I can figure, the bird that is colloquially referred to as a crow-tit in Korea is the Parrotbill - the Vinous-throated Parrotbill Sinosuthora webbiana
      http://www.hbw.com/species/vinous-throated-parrotbill-sinosuthora-webbiana

      The picture that comes up if you google "Korean Crow-tit" appears to be some kind of actual tit-but possibile leucistic (http://feederwatch.org/learn/unusual-birds/#color-variants). Not the parrotbill, though I see some superficial resemblance.

      I will have to investigate further to see if I can figure out what that mostly white bird is that is coming up in the search.

      Marc Devokaitis
      Public Information Specialist
      The Cornell Lab of Ornithology

      (Me again): The parrotbill is a fluffy brown bird, so maybe someone got it mixed up with the fluffy white bird (which is much more appealing). Really, on the internet today, someone could completely make up a bird species and most people would believe it.

      Delete
    2. Aegithalos caudatus is the name..

      Delete
    3. Blogger`s response. I looked up Shima Enaga, and found the EXACT SAME pictures that appear in this post!
      I am not sure why there is such confusion over the name of this bird. The original article didn`t give much information except to call it cute and fluffy. I shall have to do more research! Thank you for this info.

      Delete
    4. I did some googling and found that the Japanese name for their long tailed tit is 'Enaga' which could be where the second name comes from.

      Delete
  2. The bird appears to be a Long-tailed Tit (Aegithalos caudatus).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. http://www.lassemadsen.com/long-tailed-tit.html I believe you're right. The "cutesie" photos mainly show the bird from the front, giving the impression it's a white fluff-ball. Thanks for solving this!

      Delete
    2. itsatypeof longtailedtit that lives in Hokkaido Japan, they call it shimanaega. Not sure where the korean thing came from.

      Delete
  3. As a korean its really uncomfortable to see googles first result on korean crow tit is your page. U have never seen birds in korea yet when im so happy that our crow tit is getting some attention and love from people all over the world u say its fake??? What evidence do u have to say its fake??? U have none... because they r true...i grew up with them. This page is offensive

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Don't be a troll. Shut up and get a life.

      Delete
    2. Come on! Let her have an opinion.

      Delete
    3. I was very curious myself if this bird actually existed... That should not be taken offensively.. it's such a beautiful little bird it almost does look fake due to its sweet and perfect appearance....

      Delete
    4. I'm convinced it's real, but the exact name of it was in question.

      Delete
    5. Bruh, logicexpa you are an idiot. ;-; Its real they are saying but the name of it is confusing. And as a REAL korean, I assume you would know the real name of it is a " Korean Parrotbill. " But to get a white one, search up " White korean parrotbill " so i'm not really sure if you even are a korean. =-= So BOOM. Take that fake korean. :)

      Delete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I know this is probably not relevant anymore, but I wanted to try giving insight even if it's late. As far as I can tell from asking my friends and relatives who grew up in Korea, the word "baepsae" (뱁새) is typically used in conversation to refer to both the Vinous-Throated Parrotbill and the Japanese Long-Tailed Tit (which is colloquially called the Korean Crow-Tit). I think the Parrotbill is the more official/proper translation, but the reason the Long-Tail appears so often when you search "Korean Crow-Tit" seems to be because most Koreans think it's the cuter of the two and the word is used to refer to the Long-Tail far more often than the Parrotbill as a result. (But that's just what I've learned from people around me. I can't confirm anything for 100% certain.)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh, it's relevant! I'm far more interested in birds now than I was when I wrote this. And the tone of it was meant to be flippant and send up the quasi-ornithology that permeates such pages as Sunny Skyz. It's a feel-good site which puts feeling good ahead of facts, and maybe we all need a dose of that now. In any case, I do appreciate your information. I became mixed up in part because I expected a parrotbill to have an enormous bill like a parrot. But in any case, it's one cute ball of fluff.

      Delete
  6. This is the Japanese Longtailed tit! :) Probably the cutest bird to ever exist imo

    ReplyDelete
  7. Replies
    1. Absolutely true....This is the tight name. ..checked everywhere ...On YouTube too..Thanks so much ..

      Delete
    2. Right name..Thanks a bunch ..

      Delete
  8. Thank you for this article, I like it a lot. Exactly my thougs, how many people just accept it. And thank you for the comments. Nice to find the real identity of these lovely fluffy cotton ball with little wings.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for your comments!I didn't know there would be so much discussion on this topic.

      Delete
  9. Hello! I came across this post by accident but wanted to add that here in Europe we have a variant which is called Codibugnolo (meaning long tailed) - it's a tiny white bird with black stripes (pretty similar to the 'Korean Crow Tit').
    Also about the cotton-like appeareance, like someone already said, it could just be the bird fluffing up its feathers from the cold.. my budgies sometimes look like that when they clean themselves, other times they completely puff out and look like starving pinschers haha!
    Hope I didn't intrude with this comment~

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. On the contrary, I love getting comments! I was surprised at the response to this one. Yes, when I look at the photos again, it does look as if the birds are puffed up from the cold. This makes them especially fluffy and cute. But I was a bit annoyed at the "cute photo of the week" tone of the article. I had birds until a baby lovebird (Paco) died after only a few weeks. It was devastating, as no one knew why this happened. Then my daughter convinced me to get a cat (Bentley), whom I love to pieces, so I didn't get another bird. But I still miss her so much. I love to take videos of birds, then try to identify them. Again, thanks for your comment.

      Delete
  10. It is a species of lomg tailed tit that mostly resides in Hokkaido, Japan known as Shima Enaga and the white floofy balls are only native to japan. Other variants have different colours

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for the information! I'm so happy about the comments I've had here.

      Delete
  11. It is Aegithalos caudatus caudatus (sub species) I'm not sure why the Cornelle Lab of Ornithology couldn't clarify the issue here.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Adding onto the information above, the bird is not a Japan-limited bird. it's habitat extends from Asia to Mediterranean. One reason why the photo shows white colouring is because it is a migratory bird that changes its colour depending on the season. I just wanted to correct the misinformatin about the bird being Japanese.

    ReplyDelete
  13. For everyone saying this is a Japan-only bird, it's actually widespread all across Central/East Asia and Europe and (gasp) even Korea! They're a migratory species and change the color of their plumage from pinkish-gray to the winter black/white. Yes, the adorable white cotton ball can also be found in places like Germany. As for the 'fake' Korean crow-tit, Aka the Baepsae - Vinous-Throated parrotbill. It looks very similar to the long-tailed tit and also lives in places like Korea, Vietnam and Japan.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long-tailed_tit#/media/File:Parks.Range.Aegithalos.caudatus.caudatus.jpg

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you so much! How I wish the people who post photos of "adorable white puff-balls" (or whatever they call them) would take the time to find out what they are. This post has gotten more discussion than almost any other (except George Gershwin's illegitimate son/Victorian post-mortem photography).

      Delete
    2. Yes finally, we have them here in Sweden too! Here they're called stjärtmes in Swedish. Lovely small bird. All this 'controversy' about this bird just shows how easy people trust what they read online, kindly source check please. :)

      Delete
    3. Thank you for the info. I've had two years' worth of comments and all of it is interesting and fills in the picture for me. The original article was mainly interested in how it looked like a "fluffy little cotton ball with wings".

      Delete
    4. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
    5. Tried to post a link but couldn't. Yes, it's definitely the same bird. The photo looks like it's one of the same ones from the original post.

      Delete
    6. I knew it was a real bird!! I can't say it didn't exist.

      Delete
  14. Replies
    1. tit noun
      Definition of tit
      : any of various small plump often long-tailed oscine birds (family Paridae) of Eurasia and Africa that are related to the chickadees and titmice

      Delete
  15. these birds are real, except they are not called korean crow tit they are called Long tailed tit and they are from Japan. It's funny how dumb people trying to be smart and write blog about it.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Well some Koreans mistake this too that the "baepsae" in the proverb have the same last name as longtail-tits but it's specie is actually a parrotbill. (So that picture is not baepsae:( )

    Longtail-tits are commonly seen in Europe and Asia, and definitely not ONLY LIVING IN JAPAN bird because it is one of the seasonally immigranting bird. (One example, that white ball also live in Kamchatka Peninsula, which is in Europe.)

    Lastly, i think people call it korean longtail-tits because it got popular in Korea first and eventually made other countries to recognize the bird.

    I hope this information helped :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you! It's so cool to still be getting comments on this post.

      Delete
  17. Looks like a white Chickadee to me. What kind of sound does it make? Chick a dee dee dee? Then it is.

    What else do you see there? Here today at minus 14, I see Magpies, Chickadees, White Nuthatches, Crows, and Blue Jays.

    Canada

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Cool! We had very few birds except chickadees, then moved the suet feeder up where the squirrels couldn't get it. We now get Steller's jays, nuthatches, varied thrush, spotted towhee, flickers (gorgeous), downy woodpeckers, juncos, and two huge ravens, along with a few others. I also video'd a family of pileated woodpeckers along a local trail. Wowsy!Some years we get next to none.

      Delete
    2. Ever notice the smallest birds are the sassiest? Chickadees can be almost obnoxious and land on the feeder as I'm refilling it.

      Delete
  18. I just got this new comment via email, but I can`t track it down here!: Gamer38 has left a new comment on the post "FAKE BIRD NEWS! The Korean Crow-Tit":

    I thought it was Shima Enaga?

    Blogger`s response. I looked up Shima Enaga, and found the EXACT SAME pictures that I have in this post!
    I am not sure why there is such confusion over the name of this bird. The original article didn`t give much information except to call it cute and fluffy. I shall have to do more research!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This bird is an actual bird whoever says it is not. I have proof that it came from an island in Japan, called Hokkaido Island (http://earthporm.com/cute-animals-from-hokkaido/).Let's see if that works as a proof. This bird is not a hoax but an actual species.

      Delete
    2. There's no argument that it's an actual bird. What we were trying to find out was the name/species, and there were a lot of different opinions on it.

      Delete
  19. I am pretty sure it's just people being diverse. I mean, some species do have several names right? I guess some people just like calling the shima enaga the korean crow tit.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. What struck me about the original article was the gushing tone of it and the fact that the writer of it probably didn't care what kind of bird it was, just saw it as a cute little fuzzy cotton ball. In many of the pictures, it's fluffed out, maybe from the cold, so looks fatter and fluffier.

      Delete
  20. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  21. It is a true species.
    Have you seen tits, great tits, coal tits and Eurasian blue tits?
    The subspecies variations in color patterns, and floofiness depends on geographic area; but the Tit is a real species if bird.
    What it is called in other languages matter? There are things that have no direct translation and doesn't make sense when you ask for a direct translation.
    Like the word for triangle in a Filipino language is directly translated into "three even sides" (pretty much repeats in the same pattern for every polygon.)


    Here is more into the history of the word Baepsae by a linguist, the meaning and even includes the wrong assumptions previously mentioned about the long tailed tit actually being a parrotbill.
    https://linguaholic.com/linguablog/the-meaning-of-crow-tit/

    But keep in mind that direct translations and what things are called in other languages do not always coincide.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for the information! My curiosity about birds has burgeoned in the past few years,and discovering/taking videos for YouTube of unfamiliar species is a major hobby.

      Delete
  22. Hello, to all the confusion happening, I will be saying the real name of the mystery bird. A korean parrotbill. That is the real name of it in English.

    ReplyDelete
  23. I'm here April 27, 2020. Thanks for that link to the BTS Baepsae/crow tit explanation. I think this post will never die, as long as people are searching for the Korean Crow Tit. It's a good song, by the way.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, this has been the longest thread ever (three years!) It was meant to be a "puff piece" about how internet culture trivializes nature, inventing details to suit themselves. I didn't know it would gain so much serious comment! Thanks for commenting.

      Delete
  24. Please change the Title of the article because it really confuses the reader that it's a FAKE BIRD. It's very strange that your blog post about FAKE BIRD is the first search on google.

    Change the FAKE BIRD part please.

    ReplyDelete
  25. I won't do that, as the entire article was meant as satire about popular culture! It's not a scientific or ornothological piece at all. When humor falls flat, people become decidedly un-humorous. If people are at all curious, they can quickly find out for themselves, and the crow tits' image will not suffer. By the way, I have had several dozen comments claiming THEY are the only ones who have the correct information. That's a record for this blog, which I've been keeping for eight years, but I still don't know why it has drawn such a response

    ReplyDelete
  26. A passing buy Korean here.
    In Korea that bird is called 흰머리오목눈이. More sophisticated name would be Aegithalos caudatus caudatus. In English it's called long-tailed tit. A lot of Koreans would mistake this bird is 뱁새 (if you type this word into Google, you'll probably get that white ploof) but that's a different kind of bird. 뱁새, actually is the parrotbill. Vinous-throated parrotbill is what I can get. It's also called Sinosuthora webbiana.

    Tits are migratory birds to Korea. They come in winter and leave when the spring comes.
    But parrotbills are native to the land. They stay in Korea 24/7.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. excuse some typos. bird 'a's 뱁새 not 'i's.

      Delete
    2. Exactly! Baepsaes are parrotbills - brownish fluffs found in Korea as well as elsewhere. The white fluffs are long tailed tits that are migratory birds that stay from Europe to Asia.

      I think this post also explains well: https://aminoapps.com/c/btsarmy/page/blog/fake-bird-news-alert-baepsae-does-not-mean-crow-tit/D8BQ_p81hPurDKYqJJKgwMxBNWMKXg17dg

      Delete
  27. I came across your article today and found it super interesting because I painted one of these birds and titled it Korean Crow Tit. I have added more info to my description of the painting after reading this and the comments. You can see my painting here: https://jani-freimann.pixels.com/featured/korean-crow-tit-jani-freimann.html

    ReplyDelete
  28. Hi! I'm a South Korean currently studying in the U.S. I came across this blog post and couldn't help but leave a message.

    So the white fluffy bird is actually a Long-tailed tit. In Korean, it's "오목눈이." This Korean YouTuber uploaded a video about how the Korean baepsae is commonly mistakened with it.

    Link to video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S-mTP52IqM4. It's in Korean but when you look at 00:47, she explains with the visuals.

    The long tailed tit is a common bird found throughout Europe and the Palearctic. Here is the distribution map from Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long-tailed_tit#/media/File:Schwanzmeise_(Aegithalos_caudatus)_distribution_map.png.

    So, it is a lovely bird that is found throughout Eurasia. Koreans have seen it throughout its history and called it "오목눈이" while in different cultures, they are called something else.

    So I think the "Korean crow tit" is not the right name for the fluffy bird because 1) Birds don't have nationalities 2) it's a long tailed tit.

    The notion that it's a Japanese bird or a Korean bird or any other nationality bird is pretty ridiculous. Birds are birds and they are lovely! :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for the enlightening comments! I am amazed this piece drew such attention. I'm a novice bird-watcher and eager for any information I can get. I'm going to attempt to post the live links in your comment.

      Delete
    2. U r a Korean guy and agree that it is a long tail tit?
      👍👍👍

      Delete
  29. Oh, sorry. I'm just a guy who's finding for bird pets and found this cute chubby little one.. So, to be exact, is it chubby and cute and the same color? Does it exist?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm still getting comments on it after 4 years, so if it doesn't exist, then perhaps it should. I myself kept lovebirds before I got a cat, and I recommend them so long as they are socialized from the beginning. They're very sweet and become very attached to humans.

      Delete
    2. I'm the Unknown guy yesterday... So, is it just about the name only or is it linked to the bird cuteness?

      Delete
  30. I think the original article on Sunny Skyz (!) only cared about the cuteness, and wasn't too concerned with correctly identifying the species. As you can see from the comments, there's a lot of discussion about it.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Well this bird is well known in China and was called "北长尾山雀", meaning "northern long-tailed tit", because it exist in the north-east China (the part surrounded by russia and korea). There is a mandarin wiki page of it https://zh.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E5%8C%97%E9%95%BF%E5%B0%BE%E5%B1%B1%E9%9B%80 , however it is wrongly redirected to "long-tailed tit" if you try to open the english version of this page.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The northern long-tailed tit used to be recognized as a subspecies of Silver-throated bushtit, but researches found that it is actually a independent species.

      Delete

Comments